Experiment 252
“D2: the one-run decider's power and cost on F1.4's hand key schedules and on F6.1's moves, one free alphabet: 24 clean and 24 Sanborn-style plants per class, each on a setting K4 itself fits” D2 (issue #77), first measurement. D1 was decided on 2026-10-28 (#100): one design-2 run, copies climbed one at a time, qualifies for one free alphabet. Its power was measured only on plain periodic keys (F1.1, L23 and L26). Here 0140's compiled climb is generalised from 'key letter i mod L, reading in carved order' to any slot map and any reading order, so the same climb runs on F1.4's key schedules (skip, stutter, back and forth, triangle, square, line restart) and on F6.1's moves (0129/0130's type-1 library, either order); its power is measured per cell class on settings K4 itself fits, with the time per climb, and every cost-blocked one-alphabet cell is re-costed from it.
1
The experiment method What the method does with the 24 known letters.
Two groups of possible ciphers were left untested because each candidate setting took half an hour to judge, and there are hundreds (key-skipping rules) or hundreds of thousands (a shuffle of the letters, then the cipher table). A faster judge was approved yesterday. Before using it here we check that it still finds hidden test messages in these two groups, and time it, so we know what testing every candidate would cost.
1.1
The method at work The carved letters go in at the top; the reading comes out at the bottom.
the idea D2: yesterday's cheaper judge (one search instead of ten) checked on two more kinds of cipher, key-skipping rules and a shuffle before or after the table.
the check 192 planted messages, 6 scrambled copies each, 1344 searches; the same search as 0140, generalised and checked to give 0140's own scores.
the bound Found 37, 37, 31 and 32 of 48 (chance 7). Deciding every setting K4 fits costs 41 core-hours for F1.4, 248 for F6.1 at lengths 6-10, 7,649 for F6.1 at 11-26.
2
Experiment lineage What this experiment was built on, from the lineage page: 17 experiments before it, back to the root of its line. Its number is in bold.
× error or timeout
3
Best candidate against the known letters This experiment produced no candidate: the search ruled everything out before a full text was built. Its product is the bounded negative under Result and bounds below.
4
Walkthrough, by hand Redo the method on a few letters with pencil and paper.
Pick a key-skipping rule (say: one key letter skipped every 7 letters, key of 11 letters) or a letter shuffle followed by a key of 9 letters.
Write down, for each of the 97 carved letters, which key letter enciphered it.
Hide a test message under that rule with a shuffled alphabet and a random key.
Make six scrambled copies of its ciphertext that the same rule could still have produced.
Run one tempering search on the hidden message and on each copy, scoring the readings as English.
The rule's judge works if the hidden message scores above all six copies; repeat for 48 messages per group and time each search.
the worksheet: the first steps by hand, on squared paper 5
Worked example, generated The same steps run by the code on the real letters.
D2 measures the one-run decider on settings other than a plain repeating key.
setting skip one key letter every 7 letters, 11 key letters
slot map place 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ...
key letter 1 2 3 4 5 6 8 9 10 ... (letter 7 skipped)
a hidden message under that slot map and its six scrambled copies get one tempering search each;
found when the hidden message's best English score is above all six copies'.
The time per search times the settings K4 fits gives the cost of deciding the whole cell.
6
Hypothesis, for a cryptanalyst Family, key space, the constraint under test, and the clues it reads.
F1.4 (hand key schedules, C20(d), 0126-0128) and F6.1 (one free alphabet before or after a type-1 move, C1(a), 0129 , 0130 ) were closed exact where no setting fits and blocked by cost where K4 fits at the copies' rate: 555 one-alphabet slot partitions under the schedules (0127 , 0128 ) and about 443,000 (move, order, form, length) settings (0129 , 0130 ), each needing F1.5's design-2 decider at 20-30 min. D1 (0228 , 0229 ) found one tempering run as strong as ten for one free alphabet (pooled 66 of 96 plants against 67), and Alexis allowed it with every close stating its measured power. The decider's climb (0140 ) only needs, for each carved letter, which key slot enciphered it and where it stands in the message; the known letters give the same same-slot checks. So one generalised climb covers both families. Unknown: its power on these slot structures (a schedule gives uneven slot sizes; a move scatters the known places over the slots) and its time per setting. Measured on settings drawn from those K4 fits, so the power is the power of the decisions D2 reopens. Clue entries: C20(d) (the tableau rows and schedules as Sanborn's 'slightly different' use of the table), C1(a) (a move, then the table).
7
Prediction Written before the run; the result decides it.
Generalised climb reproduces 0140 's scores exactly on plain periodic settings. One-run power (found above all 6 own copies, null 1/7): F1.4 schedules clean about 0.8, Sanborn-style about 0.6; F6.1 at lengths 8-10 higher (about 0.9 and 0.7, more checks per slot); F6.1 at 11-26 about 0.7 and 0.55. Every class pooled at least 0.5. Cost: F1.4's one-alphabet residue (a few thousand full settings over both forms) under 100 core-hours, so it reopens within the $20 line; F6.1 at lengths 6-10 (about 7,400 settings) around 150 core-hours, near the line; F6.1 at 11-26 above 5,000 core-hours, which waits for money. Zero candidates.
8
Method
The climb: 0140 's C source, patched in four places (a slot per carved letter instead of i mod L, a message place per carved letter, the added form beside Beaufort, the known places given as carved places), checked against 0140 's unpatched library on the same seeds.
F1.4 settings: every schedule of 0128 (skip m 2-30, stutter, triangle, square, line restart, back and forth) at every slot count, as a slot map over all 97 places, deduplicated; each decided exactly on K4 in both forms with 0128 's decide(); the fitting ones are the cost count.
F6.1 settings: 0129 's library (27,852 maps), order A (move, then table) and B (table, then move), both forms; K4's fits recounted exactly at lengths 6-10 with 0129 's decide(); 11-26 taken from 0129 and 0130 's records.
Four classes: F1.4 skip, F1.4 other schedules, F6.1 lengths 8-10, F6.1 lengths 11-26. Per class 24 clean plants (Carter windows, 0120 's rule) and 24 Sanborn-style (0226 's classes: X stops, K1-K3 windows, three letters changed), each on its own setting drawn at random from K4's fitting settings in the class, random alphabet and key; 6 own copies each, shuffles that the exact decider fits at that setting.
One tempering run per text (16 replicas x 625 rounds x 1000 moves, 0140 's temperatures), time recorded. A plant is found when its best is strictly above all 6 own copies' bests.
Cost per setting = time per climb x (1 + 3.10, the expected copies climbed one at a time against 12) + time to make the copies; total per cell = cost x K4's fitting settings, in core-hours and Modal dollars.
9
Result and bounds The harness's record: candidates, gates, loss, and the negative result this experiment leaves behind.
0 candidates returned
0 passed every gate
0/24 known letters, best
– lowest loss
none champion before
power pooled: F1.4 skip [37, 48], F1.4 other [37, 48], F6.1 8-10 [31, 48], F6.1 11-26 [32, 48]; cost: F1.4 skip 2016 settings 39.1 core-h, F1.4 other 77 settings 1.5 core-h, F6.1 6-10 7443 settings 247.7 core-h, F6.1 11-26 435693 settings 7648.8 core-h
What was searched, as the harness recorded it.
item D2 decider D1's one-run decider: 0140's compiled tempering, one run (16 x 625 x 1000), generalised to any slot map and reading order self check against 0140 23, -5.238, -5.238 26, -5.13, -5.13 f14 settings listed F1.4 skip 11,164 F1.4 other 1,482 f14 k4 fitting settings 2,093 f14 k4 fitting by group F1.4 skip 2,016 F1.4 other 77 f14 k4 fitting partitions F1.4 skip 461 F1.4 other 52 f61 k4 fits 6 10 recount BV10 2,831 BV8 782 BB10 1,389 BB8 221 AV8 191 AV9 444 AB9 174 AB10 301 BV7 230 BB7 89 AV10 641 AV7 48 BB6 8 AB8 54 AB7 14 BV6 23 AB6 1 AV6 2 f61 k4 fits 11 26 from 0129 0130 435,693 f61 records 6 10 AV 2, 48, 191, 444, 641 AB 1, 16, 54, 174, 301 BV 23, 231, 782, 0, 2,831 BB 8, 89, 221, 0, 1,389 plants per class 48 own copies 6 null per plant 1/7 plants without copies none power F1.4 skip/clean 18, 24 F1.4 skip/sanborn 19, 24 F1.4 skip/pooled 37, 48 F1.4 other/clean 19, 24 F1.4 other/sanborn 18, 24 F1.4 other/pooled 37, 48 F6.1 8-10/clean 12, 24 F6.1 8-10/sanborn 19, 24 F6.1 8-10/pooled 31, 48 F6.1 11-26/clean 15, 24 F6.1 11-26/sanborn 17, 24 F6.1 11-26/pooled 32, 48 reference one run 0229 L23 clean 23, 24 sanborn 14, 24 L26 clean 15, 24 sanborn 14, 24 pooled 66, 96 seconds per climb F1.4 skip 16.56 F1.4 other 16.1 F6.1 8-10 28.75 F6.1 11-26 14.97 copy core seconds each 0.152 copy tries median 17 sequential copies expected 3.1 cost F1.4 skip settings 2,016 core seconds per setting 69.8 core hours 39.1 modal dollars ideal 1.9 modal dollars at half efficiency 3.8 power pooled 37, 48 F1.4 other settings 77 core seconds per setting 67.9 core hours 1.5 modal dollars ideal 0.1 modal dollars at half efficiency 0.1 power pooled 37, 48 F6.1 6-10 settings 7,443 core seconds per setting 119.8 core hours 247.7 modal dollars ideal 12.2 modal dollars at half efficiency 24.4 power pooled 31, 48 F6.1 11-26 settings 435,693 core seconds per setting 63.2 core hours 7,648.8 modal dollars ideal 376 modal dollars at half efficiency 752 power pooled 32, 48 dollars per core hour 0.049 plants F1.4 skip/0 cls clean setting B skip m=18 phi=6 n=26 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.124 letters right 46 F1.4 skip/1 cls clean setting B skip m=25 phi=24 n=17 nslots 17 form B found no margin -0.141 letters right 43 F1.4 skip/2 cls clean setting B skip m=12 phi=2 n=25 nslots 25 form B found yes margin 0.214 letters right 38 F1.4 skip/3 cls clean setting B skip m=22 phi=20 n=12 nslots 12 form B found yes margin 0.227 letters right 42 F1.4 skip/4 cls clean setting B skip m=14 phi=10 n=22 nslots 22 form V found yes margin 0.211 letters right 37 F1.4 skip/5 cls clean setting B skip m=28 phi=18 n=24 nslots 24 form B found no margin -0.023 letters right 42 F1.4 skip/6 cls clean setting B skip m=29 phi=10 n=21 nslots 21 form V found yes margin 0.005 letters right 30 F1.4 skip/7 cls clean setting B skip m=27 phi=22 n=14 nslots 14 form V found yes margin 0.649 letters right 51 F1.4 skip/8 cls clean setting B skip m=20 phi=14 n=16 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.201 letters right 42 F1.4 skip/9 cls clean setting B skip m=28 phi=2 n=24 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.148 letters right 34 F1.4 skip/10 cls clean setting B skip m=8 phi=6 n=23 nslots 23 form V found yes margin 0.143 letters right 39 F1.4 skip/11 cls clean setting B skip m=20 phi=14 n=16 nslots 16 form B found no margin -0.23 letters right 35 F1.4 skip/12 cls clean setting B skip m=28 phi=7 n=26 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.031 letters right 33 F1.4 skip/13 cls clean setting B skip m=22 phi=0 n=24 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.19 letters right 38 F1.4 skip/14 cls clean setting B skip m=11 phi=5 n=17 nslots 17 form B found no margin -0.147 letters right 41 F1.4 skip/15 cls clean setting B skip m=23 phi=5 n=16 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.276 letters right 44 F1.4 skip/16 cls clean setting B skip m=18 phi=10 n=26 nslots 26 form B found no margin -0.029 letters right 33 F1.4 skip/17 cls clean setting B skip m=24 phi=23 n=24 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.157 letters right 42 F1.4 skip/18 cls clean setting B skip m=24 phi=20 n=21 nslots 21 form B found yes margin 0.132 letters right 44 F1.4 skip/19 cls clean setting B skip m=25 phi=20 n=16 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.117 letters right 45 F1.4 skip/20 cls clean setting B skip m=10 phi=2 n=18 nslots 18 form B found no margin -0.081 letters right 43 F1.4 skip/21 cls clean setting B skip m=22 phi=13 n=17 nslots 17 form B found yes margin 0.155 letters right 40 F1.4 skip/22 cls clean setting B skip m=15 phi=0 n=26 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.033 letters right 44 F1.4 skip/23 cls clean setting B skip m=12 phi=2 n=17 nslots 17 form B found yes margin 0.131 letters right 37 F1.4 skip/24 cls xstops setting B skip m=21 phi=7 n=24 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.157 letters right 39 F1.4 skip/25 cls xstops setting B skip m=27 phi=2 n=14 nslots 14 form V found yes margin 0.001 letters right 40 F1.4 skip/26 cls xstops setting B skip m=5 phi=1 n=19 nslots 19 form B found yes margin 0.15 letters right 43 F1.4 skip/27 cls xstops setting B skip m=28 phi=5 n=16 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.141 letters right 43 F1.4 skip/28 cls k123 setting B skip m=27 phi=14 n=20 nslots 20 form B found yes margin 0.144 letters right 37 F1.4 skip/29 cls k123 setting B skip m=16 phi=8 n=21 nslots 21 form V found yes margin 0.493 letters right 38 F1.4 skip/30 cls k123 setting B skip m=22 phi=11 n=17 nslots 17 form B found no margin -0.011 letters right 41 F1.4 skip/31 cls k123 setting B skip m=15 phi=5 n=26 nslots 26 form V found yes margin 0.224 letters right 38 F1.4 skip/32 cls sub3 setting B skip m=11 phi=0 n=17 nslots 17 form B found yes margin 0.16 letters right 44 F1.4 skip/33 cls sub3 setting B skip m=26 phi=18 n=24 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.014 letters right 36 F1.4 skip/34 cls sub3 setting B skip m=29 phi=20 n=24 nslots 24 form B found no margin -0.061 letters right 28 F1.4 skip/35 cls sub3 setting B skip m=30 phi=3 n=16 nslots 16 form B found no margin -0.047 letters right 40 F1.4 skip/36 cls xstops setting B skip m=27 phi=11 n=24 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.04 letters right 38 F1.4 skip/37 cls xstops setting B skip m=15 phi=2 n=22 nslots 22 form V found no margin -0.037 letters right 35 F1.4 skip/38 cls xstops setting B skip m=18 phi=8 n=26 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.013 letters right 37 F1.4 skip/39 cls xstops setting B skip m=26 phi=9 n=16 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.484 letters right 40 F1.4 skip/40 cls k123 setting B skip m=30 phi=3 n=24 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.139 letters right 37 F1.4 skip/41 cls k123 setting B skip m=22 phi=8 n=24 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.073 letters right 35 F1.4 skip/42 cls k123 setting B skip m=27 phi=0 n=17 nslots 17 form B found yes margin 0.006 letters right 35 F1.4 skip/43 cls k123 setting B skip m=17 phi=12 n=24 nslots 24 form B found no margin -0.044 letters right 38 F1.4 skip/44 cls sub3 setting B skip m=11 phi=4 n=20 nslots 20 form B found yes margin 0.103 letters right 43 F1.4 skip/45 cls sub3 setting B skip m=15 phi=12 n=26 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.052 letters right 39 F1.4 skip/46 cls sub3 setting B skip m=30 phi=7 n=14 nslots 14 form V found yes margin 0.141 letters right 37 F1.4 skip/47 cls sub3 setting B skip m=29 phi=17 n=16 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.281 letters right 40 F1.4 other/0 cls clean setting D back and forth n=17 ends=once phi=11 nslots 17 form B found yes margin 0.179 letters right 39 F1.4 other/1 cls clean setting F line restart from K4's first letter n=29 nslots 29 form B found yes margin 0.088 letters right 39 F1.4 other/2 cls clean setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=22 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.012 letters right 35 F1.4 other/3 cls clean setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=8 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.044 letters right 39 F1.4 other/4 cls clean setting F line restart from K4's first letter n=31 nslots 31 form B found yes margin 0.097 letters right 38 F1.4 other/5 cls clean setting D back and forth n=23 ends=repeated phi=7 nslots 23 form B found yes margin 0.006 letters right 39 F1.4 other/6 cls clean setting D back and forth n=23 ends=repeated phi=8 nslots 23 form B found yes margin 0.078 letters right 36 F1.4 other/7 cls clean setting F line restart from line start n=30 nslots 30 form B found yes margin 0.048 letters right 34 F1.4 other/8 cls clean setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=6 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.077 letters right 30 F1.4 other/9 cls clean setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=16 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.023 letters right 34 F1.4 other/10 cls clean setting E square phi=5 n=23 nslots 12 form B found yes margin 0.343 letters right 40 F1.4 other/11 cls clean setting F line restart from line start n=16 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.455 letters right 45 F1.4 other/12 cls clean setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=3 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.033 letters right 34 F1.4 other/13 cls clean setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=10 nslots 24 form B found no margin -0.067 letters right 35 F1.4 other/14 cls clean setting D back and forth n=14 ends=repeated phi=3 nslots 14 form V found no margin -0.163 letters right 41 F1.4 other/15 cls clean setting F line restart from K4's first letter n=15 nslots 15 form B found no margin -0.238 letters right 37 F1.4 other/16 cls clean setting D back and forth n=17 ends=once phi=8 nslots 17 form B found yes margin 0.168 letters right 37 F1.4 other/17 cls clean setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=8 nslots 26 form B found no margin -0.03 letters right 32 F1.4 other/18 cls clean setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=5 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.04 letters right 38 F1.4 other/19 cls clean setting D back and forth n=17 ends=once phi=10 nslots 17 form B found yes margin 0.02 letters right 32 F1.4 other/20 cls clean setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=16 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.04 letters right 37 F1.4 other/21 cls clean setting D back and forth n=16 ends=once phi=6 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.192 letters right 43 F1.4 other/22 cls clean setting D back and forth n=14 ends=repeated phi=3 nslots 14 form V found yes margin 0.109 letters right 33 F1.4 other/23 cls clean setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=16 nslots 24 form B found no margin -0.071 letters right 30 F1.4 other/24 cls xstops setting D back and forth n=17 ends=once phi=9 nslots 17 form B found no margin -0.02 letters right 41 F1.4 other/25 cls xstops setting D back and forth n=17 ends=once phi=13 nslots 17 form B found yes margin 0.226 letters right 43 F1.4 other/26 cls xstops setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=16 nslots 26 form B found no margin -0.004 letters right 34 F1.4 other/27 cls xstops setting F line restart from line start n=30 nslots 30 form B found yes margin 0.074 letters right 37 F1.4 other/28 cls k123 setting D back and forth n=23 ends=repeated phi=7 nslots 23 form B found yes margin 0.082 letters right 33 F1.4 other/29 cls k123 setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=8 nslots 24 form B found no margin -0.119 letters right 31 F1.4 other/30 cls k123 setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=18 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.069 letters right 32 F1.4 other/31 cls k123 setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=8 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.048 letters right 37 F1.4 other/32 cls sub3 setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=15 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.177 letters right 40 F1.4 other/33 cls sub3 setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=14 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.054 letters right 38 F1.4 other/34 cls sub3 setting D back and forth n=23 ends=repeated phi=2 nslots 23 form B found no margin -0.135 letters right 33 F1.4 other/35 cls sub3 setting D back and forth n=15 ends=repeated phi=0 nslots 15 form B found yes margin 0.32 letters right 43 F1.4 other/36 cls xstops setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=18 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.089 letters right 30 F1.4 other/37 cls xstops setting E triangle phi=2 n=23 nslots 12 form B found yes margin 0.619 letters right 45 F1.4 other/38 cls xstops setting D back and forth n=23 ends=repeated phi=10 nslots 23 form B found no margin -0.083 letters right 33 F1.4 other/39 cls xstops setting F line restart from line start n=25 nslots 25 form B found yes margin 0.049 letters right 39 F1.4 other/40 cls k123 setting D back and forth n=23 ends=repeated phi=2 nslots 23 form B found yes margin 0.191 letters right 30 F1.4 other/41 cls k123 setting F line restart from K4's first letter n=16 nslots 16 form B found yes margin 0.626 letters right 36 F1.4 other/42 cls k123 setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=22 nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.048 letters right 36 F1.4 other/43 cls k123 setting D back and forth n=24 ends=once phi=12 nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.063 letters right 38 F1.4 other/44 cls sub3 setting D back and forth n=26 ends=repeated phi=22 nslots 26 form B found no margin -0.072 letters right 29 F1.4 other/45 cls sub3 setting E triangle phi=4 n=23 nslots 12 form B found yes margin 0.322 letters right 41 F1.4 other/46 cls sub3 setting E square phi=3 n=23 nslots 12 form B found yes margin 0.22 letters right 39 F1.4 other/47 cls sub3 setting D back and forth n=23 ends=repeated phi=14 nslots 23 form B found yes margin 0.084 letters right 39 F6.1 8-10/0 cls clean setting K3 rule a=32 b=45 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.353 letters right 38 F6.1 8-10/1 cls clean setting two turns cw 95,20 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.131 letters right 40 F6.1 8-10/2 cls clean setting two turns cw 33,87 inverse order A L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.416 letters right 40 F6.1 8-10/3 cls clean setting K3 rule a=48 b=11 order A L=9 B nslots 9 form B found no margin -0.194 letters right 47 F6.1 8-10/4 cls clean setting K3 rule a=19 b=9 inverse order A L=9 V nslots 9 form V found yes margin 1.253 letters right 47 F6.1 8-10/5 cls clean setting K3 rule a=55 b=10 order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found yes margin 0.355 letters right 49 F6.1 8-10/6 cls clean setting two turns cw 56,85 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.184 letters right 46 F6.1 8-10/7 cls clean setting two turns cw 18,87 inverse order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found yes margin 1.835 letters right 97 F6.1 8-10/8 cls clean setting two turns cw 62,79 inverse order A L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.516 letters right 37 F6.1 8-10/9 cls clean setting K3 rule a=82 b=59 order A L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 0.598 letters right 51 F6.1 8-10/10 cls clean setting two turns cw 58,48 order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.552 letters right 48 F6.1 8-10/11 cls clean setting K3 rule a=57 b=33 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.538 letters right 46 F6.1 8-10/12 cls clean setting two turns cw 25,87 inverse order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 0.94 letters right 48 F6.1 8-10/13 cls clean setting two turns cw 74,33 inverse order A L=9 V nslots 9 form V found yes margin 0.435 letters right 43 F6.1 8-10/14 cls clean setting two turns cw 6,54 inverse order A L=10 B nslots 10 form B found no margin -0.157 letters right 47 F6.1 8-10/15 cls clean setting K3 rule a=32 b=13 order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 0.423 letters right 47 F6.1 8-10/16 cls clean setting K3 rule a=90 b=16 order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.242 letters right 49 F6.1 8-10/17 cls clean setting two turns cw 42,6 order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found no margin -0.307 letters right 40 F6.1 8-10/18 cls clean setting two turns cw 81,57 order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found no margin -0.397 letters right 44 F6.1 8-10/19 cls clean setting K3 rule a=63 b=43 inverse order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 0.57 letters right 54 F6.1 8-10/20 cls clean setting K3 rule a=46 b=44 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.471 letters right 34 F6.1 8-10/21 cls clean setting K3 rule a=47 b=96 order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found no margin -0.452 letters right 44 F6.1 8-10/22 cls clean setting two turns cw 19,94 order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found no margin -0.154 letters right 37 F6.1 8-10/23 cls clean setting two turns cw 3,84 order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found yes margin 0.293 letters right 45 F6.1 8-10/24 cls xstops setting K3 rule a=75 b=21 inverse order A L=9 B nslots 9 form B found yes margin 0.314 letters right 46 F6.1 8-10/25 cls xstops setting two turns cw 83,96 order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found yes margin 0.124 letters right 55 F6.1 8-10/26 cls xstops setting two turns cw 95,28 order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.073 letters right 39 F6.1 8-10/27 cls xstops setting two turns cw 50,63 order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.504 letters right 59 F6.1 8-10/28 cls k123 setting K3 rule a=92 b=10 order A L=9 V nslots 9 form V found yes margin 0.041 letters right 42 F6.1 8-10/29 cls k123 setting two turns cw 51,27 order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found no margin -0.538 letters right 47 F6.1 8-10/30 cls k123 setting two turns cw 77,13 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.15 letters right 51 F6.1 8-10/31 cls k123 setting K3 rule a=59 b=3 order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 0.058 letters right 42 F6.1 8-10/32 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 74,84 order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found yes margin 0.498 letters right 56 F6.1 8-10/33 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 7,88 order B L=8 B nslots 8 form B found yes margin 0.335 letters right 61 F6.1 8-10/34 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 87,51 order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 1.684 letters right 97 F6.1 8-10/35 cls sub3 setting K3 rule a=4 b=31 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.972 letters right 61 F6.1 8-10/36 cls xstops setting two turns cw 47,88 order B L=10 B nslots 10 form B found yes margin 0.612 letters right 58 F6.1 8-10/37 cls xstops setting two turns cw 24,41 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.153 letters right 42 F6.1 8-10/38 cls xstops setting two turns cw 96,92 order A L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.293 letters right 43 F6.1 8-10/39 cls xstops setting two turns cw 48,60 order A L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.411 letters right 43 F6.1 8-10/40 cls k123 setting two turns cw 2,81 inverse order A L=9 B nslots 9 form B found no margin -0.252 letters right 47 F6.1 8-10/41 cls k123 setting two turns cw 34,42 order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found no margin -0.034 letters right 45 F6.1 8-10/42 cls k123 setting K3 rule a=31 b=20 inverse order A L=9 V nslots 9 form V found yes margin 0.558 letters right 42 F6.1 8-10/43 cls k123 setting two turns cw 86,60 order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 0.501 letters right 61 F6.1 8-10/44 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 92,65 order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 2.091 letters right 97 F6.1 8-10/45 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 79,36 inverse order A L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.115 letters right 45 F6.1 8-10/46 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 46,19 inverse order B L=10 V nslots 10 form V found yes margin 0.516 letters right 46 F6.1 8-10/47 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 24,38 order B L=8 V nslots 8 form V found yes margin 1.679 letters right 97 F6.1 11-26/0 cls clean setting two turns cw 90,38 inverse order B L=20 B nslots 20 form B found no margin -0.253 letters right 40 F6.1 11-26/1 cls clean setting K3 rule a=85 b=16 inverse order B L=25 B nslots 25 form B found yes margin 0.028 letters right 34 F6.1 11-26/2 cls clean setting two turns cw 39,8 inverse order A L=19 V nslots 19 form V found yes margin 0.003 letters right 39 F6.1 11-26/3 cls clean setting two turns cw 95,39 order A L=24 B nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.206 letters right 41 F6.1 11-26/4 cls clean setting keyword SECRET (repeats dropped) order A L=17 V nslots 17 form V found yes margin 0.049 letters right 39 F6.1 11-26/5 cls clean setting two turns cw 85,44 order A L=20 B nslots 20 form B found no margin -0.022 letters right 37 F6.1 11-26/6 cls clean setting two turns cw 43,39 order B L=11 B nslots 11 form B found no margin -0.619 letters right 39 F6.1 11-26/7 cls clean setting K3 rule a=35 b=48 inverse order A L=23 V nslots 23 form V found no margin -0.168 letters right 30 F6.1 11-26/8 cls clean setting two turns cw 80,13 order B L=25 V nslots 25 form V found yes margin 0.116 letters right 45 F6.1 11-26/9 cls clean setting two turns cw 23,76 order B L=23 V nslots 23 form V found yes margin 0.265 letters right 38 F6.1 11-26/10 cls clean setting two turns cw 39,60 order B L=24 V nslots 24 form V found yes margin 0.069 letters right 41 F6.1 11-26/11 cls clean setting two turns cw 17,39 inverse order A L=19 V nslots 19 form V found no margin -0.033 letters right 40 F6.1 11-26/12 cls clean setting K3 rule a=19 b=20 order A L=26 V nslots 26 form V found no margin -0.088 letters right 27 F6.1 11-26/13 cls clean setting two turns cw 45,72 inverse order A L=18 V nslots 18 form V found no margin -0.188 letters right 37 F6.1 11-26/14 cls clean setting K3 rule a=38 b=51 order A L=15 B nslots 15 form B found yes margin 0.21 letters right 44 F6.1 11-26/15 cls clean setting two turns cw 11,72 inverse order B L=26 V nslots 26 form V found yes margin 0.173 letters right 38 F6.1 11-26/16 cls clean setting two turns cw 62,5 order A L=24 V nslots 24 form V found yes margin 0.15 letters right 37 F6.1 11-26/17 cls clean setting K3 rule a=39 b=2 order A L=16 V nslots 16 form V found yes margin 0.038 letters right 35 F6.1 11-26/18 cls clean setting K3 rule a=86 b=3 order A L=24 B nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.141 letters right 42 F6.1 11-26/19 cls clean setting K3 rule a=30 b=8 order A L=20 V nslots 20 form V found yes margin 0.261 letters right 39 F6.1 11-26/20 cls clean setting two turns cw 83,72 order B L=18 B nslots 18 form B found yes margin 0.03 letters right 33 F6.1 11-26/21 cls clean setting K3 rule a=10 b=83 inverse order A L=23 B nslots 23 form B found yes margin 0.215 letters right 33 F6.1 11-26/22 cls clean setting two turns cw 67,13 inverse order A L=25 V nslots 25 form V found no margin -0.105 letters right 39 F6.1 11-26/23 cls clean setting two turns cw 61,56 inverse order A L=23 B nslots 23 form B found no margin -0.05 letters right 40 F6.1 11-26/24 cls xstops setting K3 rule a=49 b=9 inverse order B L=22 B nslots 22 form B found no margin -0.082 letters right 32 F6.1 11-26/25 cls xstops setting two turns cw 24,71 inverse order B L=25 B nslots 25 form B found yes margin 0.019 letters right 34 F6.1 11-26/26 cls xstops setting K3 rule a=9 b=28 order B L=18 B nslots 18 form B found yes margin 0.205 letters right 43 F6.1 11-26/27 cls xstops setting two turns cw 18,28 inverse order B L=23 V nslots 23 form V found yes margin 0.158 letters right 41 F6.1 11-26/28 cls k123 setting turn ccw 74 order B L=26 V nslots 26 form V found yes margin 0.069 letters right 41 F6.1 11-26/29 cls k123 setting two turns cw 38,54 order A L=15 B nslots 15 form B found yes margin 0.22 letters right 44 F6.1 11-26/30 cls k123 setting two turns cw 65,67 inverse order B L=18 B nslots 18 form B found yes margin 0.006 letters right 39 F6.1 11-26/31 cls k123 setting K3 rule a=2 b=16 inverse order B L=23 V nslots 23 form V found yes margin 0.004 letters right 32 F6.1 11-26/32 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 45,58 order B L=20 B nslots 20 form B found yes margin 0.109 letters right 39 F6.1 11-26/33 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 73,17 order B L=24 B nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.1 letters right 38 F6.1 11-26/34 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 21,91 order A L=24 V nslots 24 form V found no margin -0.063 letters right 33 F6.1 11-26/35 cls sub3 setting K3 rule a=8 b=44 order A L=25 V nslots 25 form V found no margin -0.056 letters right 36 F6.1 11-26/36 cls xstops setting two turns cw 9,5 order B L=24 V nslots 24 form V found yes margin 0.102 letters right 38 F6.1 11-26/37 cls xstops setting two turns cw 82,45 order A L=23 B nslots 23 form B found yes margin 0.102 letters right 45 F6.1 11-26/38 cls xstops setting two turns cw 18,67 inverse order B L=25 B nslots 25 form B found yes margin 0.096 letters right 34 F6.1 11-26/39 cls xstops setting two turns cw 92,83 order B L=14 B nslots 14 form B found no margin -0.035 letters right 40 F6.1 11-26/40 cls k123 setting K3 rule a=65 b=20 order B L=25 V nslots 25 form V found no margin -0.08 letters right 32 F6.1 11-26/41 cls k123 setting two turns cw 61,5 order B L=23 B nslots 23 form B found yes margin 0.088 letters right 35 F6.1 11-26/42 cls k123 setting two turns cw 83,51 inverse order B L=13 B nslots 13 form B found yes margin 0.246 letters right 48 F6.1 11-26/43 cls k123 setting two turns cw 29,19 inverse order A L=26 B nslots 26 form B found no margin -0.126 letters right 29 F6.1 11-26/44 cls sub3 setting K3 rule a=92 b=60 order B L=24 B nslots 24 form B found yes margin 0.207 letters right 39 F6.1 11-26/45 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 67,46 inverse order B L=14 B nslots 14 form B found yes margin 0.235 letters right 43 F6.1 11-26/46 cls sub3 setting K3 rule a=83 b=24 inverse order B L=21 V nslots 21 form V found no margin -0.277 letters right 29 F6.1 11-26/47 cls sub3 setting two turns cw 38,27 order B L=26 B nslots 26 form B found yes margin 0.124 letters right 39 climbs without start 0 texts climbed 1,344 compute seconds 869 exhaustive no expected total time about 1,350 one-run climbs at about 17 s (0229) = about 6.4 core-hours, plus the exact counts How this experiment sits among the others is on the lineage page; its family's open hypotheses are on the families page.