Pivot P21

From ciphertext only to Scheidt's mask, keyed by words

Why the search changed course at this point, what had happened before, and the change we believed was needed.

2026-10-28. After experiment 243, before 244. From F13 ciphertext only to F14 Scheidt's mask, keyed by words.

Why we pivoted then

Every F13 row is closed or blocked. F13.4f (0241) and F13.5 (0243) closed at full power: when the key is drawn from a word list, the ciphertext alone decides it (plants 32 of 32 and 40 of 40), and K4 sits inside its shuffles both times (p 0.42, p 0.099). F13.4f's second half, F13.4g (Chaocipher) and F13.6 were blocked at the desk with probes: two dictionary alphabets are beyond any screen without the known letters, the left wheel of a Chaocipher is not singled out by 97 letters, and the A13 battery sees no mask on readings chosen by English. D1 and D2 still wait on Alexis (#100).

What happened before

The change we believe is needed

F13's lesson carries straight into F14: a key made of words is a few dozen bits where a free alphabet is 88, and those cells can be decided. F14 takes Scheidt's mask in its keyed forms, with the known letters back in use: F14.1 first (two dictionary key-word alphabets plus a key word at key lengths 19-26), cost estimated before any run.

All pivots are on the pivots page; the pivots are also marked on the experiments chart and the lineage.

Rendered from the record on 2026-11-05 17:14 UTC; updated after every experiment.
view on GitHub